Half of America's Hottest Housing Markets Are in the Empire State

New York State has emerged as the unexpected epicenter of America's housing boom, claiming five of the top 10 spots for home price appreciation among the nation's 100 largest metropolitan areas, according to the Federal Housing Finance Agency's Q2 2025 data (FHFA, 2025).

In a stunning reversal of conventional wisdom about New York's real estate market, upstate and Long Island metros are outperforming traditional hotspots like Austin, Miami, and Phoenix. The data is demonstrating a shift in where American real estate value is being created.

Rochester takes the crown at #1, with home prices surging 10.3% year-over-year and 3.4% quarter-over-quarter. The Flower City's median home price of approximately $235,000 offers affordability that seems almost quaint by New York standards (Rochester Business Journal, 2025).

The New York-Jersey City-White Plains metro area ranks #3, posting 7.9% annual growth and 2.2% quarterly gains. Despite being one of the nation's most expensive markets, the New York metro continues attracting capital and residents, defying predictions of urban decline (FHFA, 2025).

Buffalo-Cheektowaga comes in at #5, with 7.5% year-over-year appreciation and 3.1% quarterly growth. The Queen City's renaissance continues as its median home price remains accessible while delivering strong returns for current homeowners (FHFA, 2025).

Albany-Schenectady-Troy claims #7, growing 7.3% annually with a modest 0.6% quarterly increase. The Capital Region benefits from stable government employment and growing tech sector investments, particularly in semiconductor manufacturing (FHFA, 2025).

Nassau County-Suffolk County rounds out at #8, with 7.1% yearly growth despite a slight 0.2% quarterly decline. Long Island's performance is particularly notable given its already elevated price points, with median homes exceeding $600,000 in many areas (FHFA, 2025).

The convergence of several factors explains New York's dominance. First, the state's metros remained relatively affordable compared to pandemic boomtowns that saw 40-50% appreciation from 2020-2022. As Visual Capitalist (2025) notes, Northeast inventory has plunged 51% below pre-pandemic levels, while Southern markets added supply, creating vastly different supply-demand dynamics.

Second, New York's economic diversification provides stability that single-industry towns lack. Rochester's universities and medical centers, Buffalo's advanced manufacturing, Albany's government and tech sectors, and Long Island's proximity to Manhattan create resilient demand. The New York metro area's continued growth despite being the nation's most expensive market underscores the enduring value of density and economic opportunity.

Third, migration patterns have shifted. While the pandemic saw outflows from New York City, many relocated within state rather than leaving entirely. Redfin (2025) data shows 66% of Rochester homebuyers search within their metro area, suggesting locals are driving demand rather than out-of-state investors.

To appreciate New York's performance, consider the laggards. Austin, Texas, once America's hottest market, ranked 93rd with prices falling 2.6% year-over-year. Phoenix sat at 81st with 0.0% growth. Miami managed just 2.2% growth, ranking 56th. Las Vegas posted negative 0.2% growth at 79th place (FHFA, 2025).

These Sun Belt metros that dominated pandemic-era headlines are now experiencing corrections as remote work policies normalize and inventory expands. Meanwhile, New York markets that seemed stagnant during COVID are capturing value as fundamentals reassert themselves.

For current homeowners, this data validates what they're experiencing: significant equity gains even in markets traditionally considered slow-growth. A Rochester homeowner who purchased for $200,000 two years ago has gained approximately $40,000 in equity. Buffalo owners have seen similar appreciation, while Long Island homeowners continue building wealth despite already-high valuations.

For prospective buyers, the situation presents challenges. With New York metros leading national appreciation while inventory remains constrained, competition intensifies. The Greater Rochester Association of Realtors reports homes selling for an average 112.7% of asking price, with some properties commanding 50-75% premiums (Rochester Business Journal, 2025).

For investors, New York's performance suggests reconsidering conventional wisdom about where opportunity exists. The state's high taxes and regulations, often cited as deterrents, haven't prevented market-leading appreciation. Indeed, these factors may have created barriers to entry that limit speculation and support sustainable growth.

Zillow forecasts continued growth for New York markets through 2025, though at moderating rates. Rochester is projected to appreciate 5.9% through year-end, suggesting the current momentum has staying power (Norada Real Estate, 2025).

The broader implication is that New York State's housing markets have entered a new phase. No longer can the state be dismissed as a high-tax, slow-growth environment for real estate. Instead, New York offers what increasingly scarce: established metros with economic diversity, infrastructure, and room for appreciation.

New York State's dominance of the FHFA rankings, with half the top 10 spots, represents more than a statistical curiosity. It signals a fundamental rebalancing of American real estate values. While speculation drove pandemic-era booms in emerging metros, New York's established cities are proving that economic fundamentals, not hype, ultimately determine long-term value.

For New Yorkers who weathered years of headlines about population losses and economic decline, this data offers vindication. The Empire State's real estate markets are doing better than surviving; they're leading the nation.

Federal Housing Finance Agency. (2025). FHFA HPI® top 100 metro area rankings. https://www.fhfa.gov/data/dashboard/fhfa-hpi-top-100-metro-area-rankings

Greater Rochester Association of Realtors. (2025, April 25). Status quo in Rochester housing market: Low supply, high demand. Rochester Business Journal. https://rbj.net/2025/04/25/status-quo-in-rochester-housing-market-low-supply-high-demand/

Norada Real Estate. (2025, February 13). Rochester housing market: Prices and forecast 2025-2026. https://www.noradarealestate.com/blog/rochester-real-estate-market/

Redfin. (2025). Rochester, NY housing market. https://www.redfin.com/city/16162/NY/Rochester/housing-market

Visual Capitalist. (2025, October). Ranked: America's fastest rising and falling housing markets. https://www.visualcapitalist.com/americas-fastest-rising-and-falling-housing-markets/

— Real Estate Investing Intelligence

Disclaimer: This newsletter is for educational purposes only and is not financial, investment, tax, legal, or accounting advice. I'm not a CPA, tax professional, financial advisor, investment advisor, broker-dealer, attorney, or any licensed professional. My content reflects personal opinions and research that should never be your sole basis for financial decisions. Tax laws and regulations are complex, change frequently, and vary by jurisdiction and individual circumstances. Before making any financial, investment, or tax decisions, consult qualified licensed professionals in your jurisdiction and conduct independent research. I make no representations or warranties about accuracy, completeness, or reliability of any information provided. All content is "as is" without warranties of any kind. You use this newsletter entirely at your own risk. I disclaim all liability for any losses, damages, costs, or expenses arising from your use of this information, including direct, indirect, incidental, consequential, or punitive damages. Past performance doesn't guarantee future results, all investments carry risk and may lose value, and tax situations are highly individual. Nothing here creates an advisor-client relationship. By reading this newsletter, you agree to these limitations, will seek appropriate professional advice before taking action, and agree to hold me harmless and indemnify me from any claims or damages arising from your use of this information.